commons-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Luc Maisonobe <>
Subject [math] should version 2.0 be targeted to Java 5 ?
Date Sun, 11 May 2008 16:27:53 GMT
Mauro Talevi recently proposed a new package for general linear 
regression ( This patch 
needs Java 5, mainly for annotations.

Mauro suggested to take the opportunity of the next [math] major version 
to switch to Java 5. A major version seems appropriate for such a 
change, but do we want to do it now ?

My personal opinion is that sticking to Java 1.3 is really obsolete and 
difficult. When I upgraded my Linux box recently, I had to search old 
backups to reinstall a JDK manually. Dropping this could simplify some 
codes (exceptions for example) and fix some errors (there is a known 
issue with unit tests since Java 1.3 does not compute trigonometric 
functions as it should).

If we decide to change minimal Java version, I would choose to target 
1.5. It is widely adopted and deployed now and has many features which 
would be useful for a mathematical library:
     - new Math functions (log10, cbrt, ulp, signum, cosh, sinh, tanh, 
hypot, expm1, log1p)
     - autoboxing
     - MathContext, RoundingMode
In addition, there are the many features that are interesting for any 
type of Java development (enums, generics, annotations).

Java 6 brings even more Math functions (copysign, getExponent, 
nextAfter, nextUp, scalb), some of which we needed to add ourselves in 
MathUtils. However, I'm not sure it is as widely deployed than Java5.

Perhaps Java 7 would bring even more functions (asinh, acosh and atanh 
are still missing ...)

What do you think ?


To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message