cocoon-users mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From "Robin Rigby" <>
Subject Re: Lowering in amount of users' posts?
Date Mon, 19 Apr 2010 08:27:38 GMT
That depends on the context in which you work: experience, environment, support.  I like the
previous comment about it being a change for the developers' benefit.

As someone working on my own with little contact with other developers, I used 2.1 at a fairly
superficial level, without troubling too much about Avalon, etc.  Worked fine but adding a
block was a pain.  I now have an app working in 2.2 but I had to deal with several simultaneous
learning curves and it took far longer than it should have done.

My 2c

  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Robby Pelssers 
  To: ; Andreas Kuehne 
  Sent: Monday, April 19, 2010 9:12 AM
  Subject: RE: Lowering in amount of users' posts?

  Maybe the learning curve got a bit steeper for Cocoon2.2 but I disagree that this is inherent
to Cocoon itself.  Cocoon2.2 still allows you to do use the sitemap as before and building
a complete webapp with optional usage of

  -          Flowscript/jxtemplate

  -          Cocoon forms

  -          Xslt

  -          …

  without ever having to write a single line of Java.


  It took me 1 week to completely make the switch from Cocoon2.1.11 to Cocoon2.2. And building
blocks and wiring them up  (dependencies) in the servlet-context.xml is really simple.


  The switch to Maven is a generic tendency seen in all open source projects, so not only
Cocoon…. Who will tell when we all switch to Craddle (and have to learn yet another build
tool and programming language Groovy).


  And the switch from Avalon to Spring was also a complete logical step… it has become the
de facto standard for doing dependency injection and it comes bundled with a lot of usefull
integration classes for most frameworks (Castor, XStream, Quartz, …) and AOP.   And for
the ones who still think the only decent JVM language is Java… think twice.


  If you ask me this discussion is more about people resisting change in Software development
in general because they have to adapt (again) to new technologies.



  Robby Pelssers


  From: Andreas Kuehne [] 
  Sent: Sunday, April 18, 2010 3:40 PM
  Subject: Re: Lowering in amount of users' posts?



  for me it's also true :
  Didn't see any real need to got to 2.2. or beyond ! 2.1 does anything for me, huge apps
with heavy load as well as quick solutions. 

  To the major problem of cocoon is : It's ready ! No burning needs for new functionality,
no major tasks on the todo list. Fiddeling with another base framework ( spring instead of
avalon ) or build tool ( maven vs. ant ) doesn't make any user more happy.

  I can do what I need any van even impress competitors with speed and performance. Maintainance
mode or not, I'm happy with it ! 



View raw message