cocoon-users mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Joerg Heinicke <>
Subject Re: XHTML Serializer block/Ajax: Bug
Date Fri, 16 Mar 2007 07:56:56 GMT
Jason Johnston <cocoon <at>> writes:

> The first issue is that XHTMLSerializer encodes all double-quotes in 
> text content as &quot;, which is of course absolutely valid XML/XHTML. 
> Unfortunately, when an XHTML document is served up with a text/html 
> mime-type, as you're doing, Firefox doesn't actually parse the document 
> with an XML parser; it instead uses the "quirky" HTML parser which 
> doesn't handle &quot; entities in script.  I suspect MSIE behaves similarly.

At least for Firefox it is not as simple as you write. IIRC you can serve XHTML
document with text/html and they are parsed as XHTML using an XML parser. But
the document itself must also match some criteria (Doctype, XML declaration?).
There are documents available about this topic on the internet, but I have no
time to search for them at the moment.

> The bad news is that apparently Dojo uses 
> document.write(), which is not allowed in XHTML, so a different error is 
> thrown.  Dojo would have to be fixed to be able to use this mime-type.

So, Dojo is not XHTML compatible at all?

> Another option might be to wrap the contents of <script> elements within 
> a CDATA section so the JS could remain unencoded but it would still 
> result in well-formed XML.  I'm not sure how some browsers would handle 
> the CDATA delimiters so they might have to be commented out so they're 
> not mistaken for script code:
> <script type="text/javascript">/*<![CDATA[*/
> while(0 < 1 && true) alert("oops");
> /*]]>*/</script>

Actually I don't like it. From an XML POV the above and the current solution are
absolutely equal. What we are going to do with such a fix is to fix awkward
browser behaviour or even wrong document contents.

If Dojo is not XHTML compatible at all, it is also clear that you shouldn't use
XHTMLSerializer at all - and we shouldn't fix the XHTMLSerializer to make the
output readable as tag soup what quirks mode actually means.

My 2c.


To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message