cocoon-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Bruno Dumon <>
Subject Re: [RT] Towards a new/another Forms Framework
Date Wed, 02 Apr 2003 09:08:26 GMT
On Wed, 2003-04-02 at 05:32, ivelin wrote:
> Bruno,
> It is funny enough that it's April 1, but your email reminds me about the
> one Torsten sent out about a year ago, not on April 1 ;)

Maybe in spirit, but not in concrete ideas (see further on...)

> > It should be possible to create a form just by describing its structure
> > in an XML file (lets call this a "form description"). I don't like the
> > fact that for XMLForm/Struts the user needs to write a bean just to hold
> > the form data. Apparently the struts people are realizing this and have
> > introduced something like 'DynaFormBeans' for this purpose. XMLForm
> > allows to use any DOM document as data-structure, but a DOM document can
> > only hold strings, and not dates or numbers.
> Since XMLForm uses JXPath, it also supports DynaBeans
> If I am not completely mistaken, most of your email describes in detail
> features of an XForms inplementation: cross field dependencies, event
> handling, generating instances from XSD. I think that Chiba is probably
> (again) your best bet in this regard.
> It has a tool which generates XForms documents and instances from XML
> Schemas.

I think this is where my approach differs from most of the other form
solutions discussed here: I'm not interested in being able to edit any
XML instance governed by any WXS or RNG schema.

I see a form as a collection of widgets holding strongly typed data
(strings, numbers, dates, and so on). There will be one special type of
widget that is a collection of a set of other widgets. So a form can
become a tree structure of widgets, each widget containing some data.

Such a form _could_ be populated with data from an XML document, and
once the form is succesfully submitted, its data could be applied back
to the XML document. But it could be used for any other purpose as well.

So in a certain sense, you could see the widget-tree as some kind of
limitted, strongly-typed XML tree, and the form description could be
seen as a special kind of XML schema. But I don't see any need to
actually use XML datastructures and validation here.

Bruno Dumon                   
Outerthought - Open Source, Java & XML Competence Support Center                

View raw message