cocoon-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Ovidiu Predescu <ovi...@apache.org>
Subject Re: Scratchpad leases (Re: [RT] what cocoon is doing wrong)
Date Wed, 26 Feb 2003 05:36:45 GMT

On Tuesday, Feb 25, 2003, at 20:57 US/Pacific, Jeff Turner wrote:

>> What would removal of the Scratchpad force on the community?
>>
>> * More controlled innovation.  Instead of anybody using it as their
>>   personal playground, it would force the development to be more in
>>   the face of the community.
>
> Hence schecoon would have been shot down in flames, as people -1'ed it 
> on
> the syntax.

I definitely agree here!

>> * If the community doesn't want to support it, move it someplace else.
>>   IOW if the community doesn't want some code in the main trunk it is
>>   for a very good reason.  The proposing developer would be encouraged
>>   to incubate the project elsewhere.
>
> Playgrounds *have* to exist.  The question is, do they happen in the
> scratchpad or on someone's hard disk.  At least in the scratchpad, 
> there
> is a chance of half-baked code inspiring others, and forming a nucleus
> for further development.
>
> I agree, there is a real problem in that scratchpad code tends to hang
> around in limbo forever, never accepted nor rejected.
>
> So how about assigning each scratchpad module a "lease"; being a
> predefined period (say 3 months) after which the code's presence in CVS
> must be reviewed.  When the lease expires, a vote is held, and the code
> either becomes official, or is rejected, or has the lease renewed.
>
> For every unit of alpha-quality code (block, scratchpad segment), we
> could have a status file (as Tony Collen suggested) indicating things
> like:
>   - code owners (cocoon-dev is not the owner yet)
>   - description (eg links to mailing list discussions)
>   - lease expiry
>
> Managed inclusion rather than exclusion.

+1

We do need a place for people to experiment with ideas, and the 
scratchpad is a good place.

Cheers,
Ovidiu

-- 
Ovidiu Predescu <ovidiu@apache.org>
http://www.google.com/search?btnI=&q=ovidiu (I'm feeling lucky)


Mime
View raw message