cocoon-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From "KUMAR,PANKAJ (HP-Cupertino,ex1)" <>
Subject RE: SOAP client and server
Date Sun, 03 Jun 2001 19:17:58 GMT
I am not a heavy SOAP user, but as a programmer when my program is acting as
a client, I would perhaps like it to use SOAP in 3 different ways --

1. Make an SOAP RPC call from an XSP, preferrably with a syntax like:
	<soap:call dest="..." method="..." ...>
	  <soap:call_args ...> ... </soap:call_args>
	  <soap:call_returns ...> ... </soap:call_returns>

I should be able to use arbitrary objects as arguments and return values.
Also, I would expect information about encoding style, namespaces, transport
binding etc. to be taken from configuration files or supplied by the

2. Send a SOAP message and receive a response ( synchronous send ),
   with a syntax like:
	<soap:send_recv dest="..." ...>
	  <soap:req_msg> ... </soap:req_msg> |
	  <soap:res_msg> ... </soap:res_msg>
   It may be possible to provide convenience tags to construct a SOAP
envelop, header fields and the body, but the programmer should have the
flexibility to build the packet in any other way possible well. Same goes
for response message ( though the convenience tags here would extract fields
from a response ).

3. Send a SOAP message asynchronously, preferrably with a syntax like:
	<soap:send dest="..." ...>
	  <soap:msg> ... </soap:msg> |

Should this functionality be available as logicsheet or a transformer?
Probably both. Logicsheet will work fine as long as I am writing an XSP that
gets compiled during generation phase but what if I inject these tags as a
result of an XSLT transformation in the middle of the Cocoon processing
pipeline? ( should that be allowed at all ? )

Haven't thought about how should a server receive a SOAP message. A straight
forward answer would seem to be a SOAP generator, but may be there is a
better way with actions ( need to understand this !! ). How about hooking up
with a SOAP server for processing SOAP message in the generator the same way
as the JSP generator hooks up with Jasper for document generation !!

> -----Original Message-----
> From: Michael Homeijer []
> Sent: Sunday, June 03, 2001 3:23 AM
> To: 'CARLTON,NADINE (HP-Cupertino,ex1) '
> Cc: ''' '
> Subject: RE: SOAP client and server
> Hi,
> The implementation I sent to the list was meant to get some 
> comment on how
> soap should be implemented in C2.
> I think my prototype gives a basic understanding about what 
> should be done
> to implement a soap client and a soap server in C2. I think 
> you'r right that
> some design decisions have to be made.
> One of them is what components have to be implemented, you 
> talk about a SAX
> state machine, Giacomo talks about Avalon components (or 
> could these be the
> same?). My understanding of C2 or Avalon doesn't go that far 
> that I can make
> such a decision.
> The other is weather to use the C1 soap syntax from Uli. My 
> reason not to
> was that the syntax should be used for both the client and 
> the server and
> imho Uli's syntax was aimed at the client. Another reason is 
> that at the
> basis of SOAP, there are response and request envelopes that 
> you sent to a
> client or server, you can just copy those envelopes from 
> and
> implement, replace or call a soap service.
> Michael Homeijer
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail:
> For additional commands, email:

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, email:

View raw message