cloudstack-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Mathias Mullins <mathias.mull...@citrix.com>
Subject Re: [VOTE] Move forward with 4.1 without a Xen-specific fix for CLOUDSTACK-2492?
Date Wed, 22 May 2013 06:59:31 GMT
-1 on this. 

New features really should be across the board for the Hypervisors. Part
of the thing that distinguishes ACS is it's support across Xen / VMware /
KVM. Do we really want to start getting in the habit of pushing forward
new features that are not across the fully functional hypervisors?

I agree with Outback this also will start to affect the Xen/XCP community
by basically setting them apart and out on what a lot of people see as a
major feature. 

I think it sets a really bad precedent. If it was Hyper-V which is not
fully functional and not a major feature-set right now, I would be +1 on
this.

MHO
Matt 



On 5/20/13 4:15 PM, "Chip Childers" <chip.childers@sungard.com> wrote:

>All,
>
>As discussed on another thread [1], we identified a bug
>(CLOUDSTACK-2492) in the current 3.x system VMs, where the System VMs
>are not configured to sync their time with either the host HV or an NTP
>service.  That bug affects the system VMs for all three primary HVs (KVM,
>Xen and vSphere).  Patches have been committed addressing vSphere and
>KVM.  It appears that a correction for Xen would require the re-build of
>a system VM image and a full round of regression testing that image.
>
>Given that the discussion thread has not resulted in a consensus on this
>issue, I unfortunately believe that the only path forward is to call for
>a formal VOTE.
>
>Please respond with one of the following:
>
>+1: proceed with 4.1 without the Xen portion of CLOUDSTACK-2492 being
>resolved
>+0: don't care one way or the other
>-1: do *not* proceed with any further 4.1 release candidates until
>CLOUDSTACK-2492 has been fully resolved
>
>-chip
>
>[1] http://markmail.org/message/rw7vciq3r33biasb


Mime
View raw message