cayenne-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Andrus Adamchik <>
Subject Re: 3.0.1 - next steps
Date Thu, 26 Aug 2010 08:12:02 GMT
Hi Ari, this all makes sense. See my comments on the details below.

On Aug 19, 2010, at 8:00 AM, Aristedes Maniatis wrote:

> As a PMC I suggest that our rules should be:

I suggest to call this "guidelines", not "rules". Please let's preserve the commonsense approach
we've been using all along. Just look at the release to see if you can spot anything wrong.
This discussion hopefully provided better understanding of the specific things that need to
be checked, but *how* everybody checks that is up to each person. In fact diversity in evaluation
techniques should in theory provide better coverage of possible holes than algorithmic rules.

> 3. All committers are encouraged to vote on releases. Committer votes will be considered
by the PMC (particularly -1 votes will be discussed) when making the final decision, but are
not binding.


> 4. Each PMC member will do the following before voting on a release:
> a. download the artifacts
> b. satisfy themselves that the source matches the appropriate svn tag (I don't know how
to do that though: how do I check that Andrus didn't accidentally build the distribution without
a clean svn checkout or that his git-svn tool didn't do something wacky?)

Technically this is doable (with a "diff -u" command against a local checkout). If somebody's
willing to do it at least occasionally, please do it. Alternatively you may look at some recent
commits and see that they are present in the source distro, or use some other simple sanity
check approach.

> d. satisfy themselves that the binary distribution is sane and passes basic usability
tests. For example, that the Cayenne modeler runs and the main jar passes some basic tests.

In line with what I said above, a user may take any extra steps (s)he deems appropriate. E.g.
stick cayenne-server.jar in a production app :-)

View raw message