avalon-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From "Leo Sutic" <leo.su...@inspireinfrastructure.com>
Subject RE: [heads-up] The version of ECM in CVS has a change in JDK reqs
Date Sat, 28 Sep 2002 13:26:53 GMT

> From: Berin Loritsch [mailto:bloritsch@apache.org] 
> One of the fundamental issues with the move from 
> ComponentManager to ServiceManager is what do we do with 
> components that do not implement the "Component" interface.  
> This is especially important because someone removed the 
> Component interface from the Monitor components in Excalibur 
> CVS.  The solution, believe it or not was already written, 
> but ECM didn't take advantage of it.
> ECM now uses a sporty new utility called a 
> ComponentProxyGenerator, which requires JDK 1.3 or higher 
> because it generates a Proxy for the component that extends 
> the component's role interface and the Component interface.  
> As a result you can use the ComponentManager to access legacy 
> systems where you don't have access or privelege to change 
> the interface.  In the end this change is for the better.
> As a result, if Cocoon wants to use the latest and greatest 
> ECM, then it must use JDK 1.3 or higher.  I am sure that JDK 
> 1.3 will help make some things easier to do in Cocoon.  Also 
> note that should Cocoon use the latest and greatest from 
> Fortress (comming to a store near you RSN) or Merlin, it 
> would have to upgrade to JDK 1.3 or better anyway.

While I'm sure the change is for the better, if anyone has
deployed Cocoon an a JDK1.2.2 system, this effectively makes
them out of luck when it comes to Cocoon bugfixes etc.

Cocoon 2.0 has been out for a year, and I think it is a severe
violation of contracts to suddely say that "sorry, you need
JDK 1.3" when Cocoon so far has maintained JDK1.2 compatibility.

See http://xml.apache.org/cocoon/installing/index.html:

    Apache Cocoon requires the following systems to be already 
    installed in your system: 

    Java Virtual Machine A Java 1.2 or later compatible virtual 
    machine must be present for both command line and servlet 
    type usage of Apache Cocoon. Note that all servlet engines 
    require a JVM to run so if you are already using servlets you 
    already have one installed. 

I bet people have made business decisions based on that information.

Somehow this contract must be maintained, at the very least for 
the 2.0 branch.

 + Avalon 4 contains the ComponentManager interface and thus 
   *all* component that claim to be Avalon 4 compatible MUST
   support the Component interface. Yes, it is deprecated, but
   unless you intend to roll out A5, Component et al. are there
   to stay and *must* be supported. Solution: Let Monitor implement 
   Component again. That would make it A4 compliant. Then there's
   no need for the proxy generator for Cocoon.

 + Maintain 2 versions of ECM - one 1.2 without the proxy and one 1.3+
   with it.

Finally, Avalon makes ***no*** promises that I could find on the 
webpages about what JDK it will run / compile on. So I think the 
promise made by the Cocoon team of supporting JDK1.2 is a bit 
impossible, and that it should be qualified to be for the 2.0 branch 
only or something.

(Avalon team: Do we promise anything in regard to JVM versions?)


To unsubscribe, e-mail:   <mailto:avalon-dev-unsubscribe@jakarta.apache.org>
For additional commands, e-mail: <mailto:avalon-dev-help@jakarta.apache.org>

View raw message