aurora-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From "Oliver, James" <>
Subject Sharded Service Coordination
Date Wed, 09 Jul 2014 17:24:39 GMT
Good morning,

My company is in the process of adopting Apache's open source stack, and I've been tasked
with building Aurora jobs to deploy a few popular open source technologies on Mesos. Aurora
is an elegant scheduler and in our estimation will met our company's needs. However, we are
struggling to meet some of the configuration requirements of some of the tools we wish to

Scenario: When a distributed service is deployed, we need to programmatically determine all
hosts selected for deployment and their reserved ports in order to properly configure the
service. We've solved this in a few not-so-elegant ways:

 1.  We wrote a Process to publish host/port information to a distributed file system, block
until {{instances}} were written, read the information and finally configure the service.
This works, but IMO it is not an elegant solution.
 2.  Next, we designed a REST API for service registration (based off of the Aurora job key)
and published this information to our ZooKeeper ensemble. This solution removes the dependency
on a pre-configured distributed file system. However, some overhead is still required (multiple
instances are necessary so as to not introduce a point of failure). Aurora jobs now require
some initial configuration to be able to communicate with the service. Communication to this
API is a little non-trivial because the REST service doesn't block until all information is
communicated – this would be problematic due to the nature of the HTTP protocol.

At this point, we realized that an even better solution might be to communicate directly to
Aurora scheduler to get this data. Seeing as Aurora scripts are just Python, we could probably
implement it in a reusable fashion…but I'm curious if anyone has already gone down this

Thank you,
James O

  • Unnamed multipart/alternative (inline, None, 0 bytes)
View raw message