ant-user mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Niklas Matthies <>
Subject Conditional target problem
Date Tue, 17 Aug 2010 22:35:10 GMT
We have something like the following (target bodies omitted):

    <target name="checkout-sources" depends="other stuff">
        <!-- takes several minutes -->

    <target name="determine-release-number"
        depends="checkout-sources" unless="release.number">
        <!-- determines release.number from sources -->

    <target name="target1" depends="determine-release-number">
        <!-- needs release.number -->

    <target name="target2" depends="checkout-sources, target1">
        <!-- needs sources and target1 -->

The problem: "ant -Drelease.number=... target1" causes
checkout-sources (and its dependencies) to be executed although there
is no need for it, as release.number is already defined.

We can't put the unless="release.number" on checkout-sources (and its
dependencies) because it would break target2 when release.number is

We can't make checkout-sources a macro (called both by target2 and by
determine-release-number) because of all its dependencies, and also
because an up-to-date check on it is highly non-trivial, so in the
target2 case it might end up being executed twice. 

We _could_ duplicate the body and the dependencies of checkout-sources
into determine-release-number (and remove the latter's dependency on
checkout-sources), but I'd have to do that for quite a number of the
dependencies as well, as they contribute to the expensiveness of
checkout-sources. The result would be a lot of redundancy, effectively
duplicating a dependency subgraph.

Is there a way to solve the problem, within a single Ant instance,
without creating redundancies?

-- Niklas Matthies

To unsubscribe, e-mail:
For additional commands, e-mail:

View raw message