ant-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From Stefan Bodewig <bode...@apache.org>
Subject <junit>, fork and CLASSPATH
Date Mon, 31 Mar 2003 14:49:13 GMT
Hi,

I'm currently looking into Bug 14971.  This bug points out an
inconsistency in <junit> that has been there for ages and I'm a bit
unsure on how to fix it.

<junit fork="true" includeantruntime="yes"> will run the forked tests
with a classpath containing ant.jar, optional.jar and junit.jar,
nothing else.

<junit fork="true" includeantruntime="no"> will run the forked tests
with whatever is in the CLASSPATH env variable as it doesn't pass an
explicit -classpath argument at all.

If the <junit> task has a nested <classpath>, things are different,
your CLASSPATH will never be used as there will always be a -classpath
argument.

I'm not sure, how this should be resolved.  Even if we add a new
attribute, I don't see a default setting that would preserve the old
behavior.  Well, maybe I do.  Something like addsystemclasspath with a
default of false that would query the native environment for
CLASSPATH.

Maybe we don't have a bug at all and we can say that you get exactly
the classpath you are asking for?  This doesn't hold as you don't get
an empty CLASSPATH when you specify nothing.

Ideas?

Stefan

Mime
View raw message