ant-dev mailing list archives

Site index · List index
Message view « Date » · « Thread »
Top « Date » · « Thread »
From "Jose Alberto Fernandez" <>
Subject Re: Exporting a Project Instance
Date Sat, 23 Mar 2002 13:08:36 GMT
From: <>

> <snip/>
> > Also notice that you cannot reproduce the REAL project XML from the 
> > content of the tasks
> > the reason being that tasks are not aware of property expansion. By the 
> > time calls are made
> > into the task all property expansion has already happened. The 
> > resulting XML, IMO, is useless.
> > 90% of the meaning of an XML buildfile is in the properties.
> I hadn't thought of this as my use case doesn't worry about properties 
> (see
> below).
Ahh, but once you think on changing the entire ANT framework, then you cannot 
just think on your limited case scenario.

> > In other words this is the wrong way to go. If ANT1.x decides to move 
> > into an all UnknownElement or
> > RuntimeConfigurable approach, then most of the issues above will 
> > disappear. But still I have a question
> > why do you want to reconstitute the ANT1.x XML?
> I have a code generator which produces a different number of Java classes
> based upon the input).  The names of these classes are also dependent on
> the input.  To make it that bit easier to work with the generated code I 
> also
> generate a build.xml file.  I currently do this by hand crafting the XML 
> using
> StringBuffer.append(...).  For example if I add a copy task to the 
> project, I
> simply do something like:
> buff.append("<copy file=\"").append(sourceFileName).append("\"");
> buff.append(" tofile=\"").append(destFilename).append("\"");
> buff.append(" />\n");

Why don't you use JDom instead of StringBuffers?

Using JDOM you actually can build your buildfile *easily* as an XML tree
and then you just ask JDOM to Serialize it into a file or watever.
In other words you can achieve what Adam was talking about today.
For you limited case.

Jose Alberto

To unsubscribe, e-mail:   <>
For additional commands, e-mail: <>

View raw message